The searchable database of retracted papers launched by RetractionWatch shows 982 papers from India have been retracted so far. Of these, 330 have been retracted for plagiarism and, surprisingly, 118 papers for image duplication and/or manipulation. The number of papers retracted for image issues has suddenly increased since 2016, with 37 papers retracted in 2018 alone.
Unlike plagiarism in papers published in scientific journals, image duplication in the same paper or in different papers and image manipulation have hardly received any attention. But the high-profile retraction in 2006 of South Korean stem cell researcher Hwang Woo Suk’s paper published in 2005 in Science turned the spotlight on image manipulation. Two photographs in the same figure in the paper were found to be partial duplication.
Since 2011 and particularly in the last three-four years more papers are getting flagged for problematic images. And the number of papers with questionable images getting retracted is also growing suddenly.
A searchable database of retracted papers launched in October last year by RetractionWatch blog has about 18,000 papers since the 1970s. The database was screened for retracted papers from India. Of the 982 papers that have been retracted so far from India, 330 have been for plagiarism. Surprisingly, 118 papers from India have been retracted for image duplication and/or manipulation.
Of the 118, 54 papers have been retracted for image manipulation and the remaining for image duplication. There are a few papers that contain both image duplication and manipulation. However, nine retracted papers did not show up during the search taking the total number of papers retracted for image duplication and/or manipulation to 127.
The number of papers retracted has suddenly increased since 2016, with 18 papers retracted in 2019, 37 papers in 2018, 15 papers in 2015 and 21 papers in 2016. At 20, Dr. Rashmi Madhuri and Prashant Sharma of IIT Dhanbad have the most number of retracted papers. They are co-authors in all papers.
While 127 papers retracted might be a fraction of the number of articles published each year from India, it is still a huge number considering how reluctant journal publishers are in retracting papers.
“Journals are not very responsive [in retracting or correcting papers with problematic images],” Dr. Elisabeth Bik who is a Science Consultant at Harbers-Bik LLC, San Francisco, California and an expert in identifying duplication and manipulation in images says in an email. “Of the 782 papers that I reported in 2014 and 2015 [for image duplication and manipulation], 44 have been retracted, two have an expression of concern, and 196 have a corrigendum or erratum. The remaining 540 papers have not been corrected, as far as I know. That means that five years after problematic papers have been reported, only one third of them have been corrected or retracted. That number is much too low, in my opinion, and it means that journals are not very willing to take any action.” The reluctance becomes all the more glaring as at least 50% of papers had images suggestive of deliberate manipulation.
Dr. Bik along with two other authors found 782 papers with problematic images from a dataset of 20,000 papers published by researchers from many countries in 40 journals from 1995 to 2014. The study was published in 2016 in the journal mBio. The authors reported the problematic papers to the respective journals.
Compared with the U.S and China, there are relatively fewer papers from India that gets published. But Bik’s study found India had 1.93 higher-than-predicted ratio of papers containing image duplication.
How widespread is image manipulation
In 2018, Dr. Bik and others analysed 960 papers published in Molecular and Cellular Biology from 2009 to 2016. They found 59 papers contained duplicated images leading corrections for 41 papers and five retractions. “The majority of inappropriate image duplications result from errors during figure preparation that can be remedied by correction,” they write. The journal instituted a pilot program where all the accepted papers were screened for images prior to publication. In the beginning of 2013, in just two months, the journal identified image concerns in 12 of the 83 papers. “Image screening can identify papers with problematic images prior to publication… and required an average of 30 minutes of staff time per problematic paper,” they write.
According to a small study of 200 papers that were about to be accepted for publication in The Journal of Clinical Investigation, 21% (42 of 200) of papers had issues with Western blots and 27.5% (55 of 200) of papers had problems with images. The study was carried out between July 2018 and first week of February 2019. They found 49 of 55 papers with image issues were “minor transgressions”.
“The absolute number of retractions has risen over the past few decades, from fewer than 100 annually before 2000 to nearly 1,000 in 2014. But retractions remain relatively rare: Only about four of every 10,000 papers are now retracted,” says an article in the journal Science.
The good news is that journals are beginning to shed their reluctance to retract papers involving problematic images. “There appears to be a trend towards a faster response time; perhaps under the influence of social media discussions or a shift of opinion of the general audience that these cases should be handled faster,” Dr. Bik says.
How checking for image manipulation evolved
Unlike in the case of plagiarism where there are software available to detect it and almost all journals routinely use them, no such software or system is available for detecting image duplication and manipulation. But that shortcoming is to a small extent getting addressed in a completely different way. The Journal of Clinical Investigation is relying on Dr. Corinne L. Williams, an editor who has an “excellent eye for image duplication”, to find such faulty papers.
“The Journal of Cell Biological has been a pioneer though, screening images after acceptances very carefully and asking for originals if there was any doubt. But only if they suspected something,” says Dr. Bik. Way back in 2013, the Molecular and Cellular Biology “instituted a program to analyse the figures in all accepted manuscripts before publication, modelled after a similar program used by the Journal of Cell Biology,” Dr. Bik and others write in the 2018 paper.
In 2002, much before Hwang Woo-Suk’s case of image manipulation hit the news headlines, the Journal of Cell Biology (JCB) became the first journal to begin screening all accepted papers for image manipulation. It all started when Dr. Mike Rossner, Editor of JCB, saw an “obvious black box around one of the bands in a Western blot” in a paper accepted for publication. He realised that the particular band “had been adjusted”, and as a result the paper’s acceptance was cancelled. “Digital images can be easily examined for evidence of manipulation,” Dr. Rossner writes in a 2007 editorial.
“At the Journal of Cell Biology we examine all digital images in all accepted manuscripts for evidence of manipulation,” Dr. Rossner writes in a March 2006 article in The Scientist. “During our three and a half years of screening experience at the JCB, we have had to revoke the acceptance of 1% of papers that passed peer review because we detected fraudulent image manipulation that affected interpretation of the data.”
Now, more and more journals have started demanding for unedited, raw image data from authors at some stage of the publication process.
PubPeer’s crucial role in cleaning the scientific literature
A catalyst that is bringing about this change is the PubPeer website, which allows independent researchers to publish post-publication review of scientific papers. The independent researchers are “increasingly making use of PubPeer or social media to describe papers of concern,” says Dr. Bik who is quite active on PubPeer and prefers to use her actual name instead of going anonymous as most other researchers posting on the website do.
“Almost all remarks about problematic images on PubPeer appear correct, and there is an active community that will comment if it does not agree,” she adds. The popularity of PubPeer can be gauged by the regular mention of the website in articles on science misconduct. “So we can assume that more and more people are becoming familiar with PubPeer,” says Dr. Bik.
And the results are showing. At least one paper from India with questionable image gets posted on PubPeer at least once in two days. With The Hindu reporting on papers with problematic images from half a dozen institutions, there is a sudden rush by Indian researchers to post their responses on PubPeer.
Papers retracted for duplicated and/or manipulated images
1) Caspase-3 induced Apoptosis in Transgenic Zebrafish
Chiranjib Chakraborty, Gargi Saha, Biplab Sarkar, S Pal, T K Chatterjee, A K Sadhu
Biotechnology Letters, February 2006
Banumathi Elayappan, Haribalaganesh Ravinarayannan, Sheik Pran Babu Sardar Pasha, Kyung-jin Lee, Sangiliyandi Gurunathan
Angiogenesis, July 2011
Kalimuthu Kalishwaralal, Sardarpasha Sheikpranbabu, Selvaraj BarathManiKanth, Ravinarayanan Haribalaganesh, Sureshbabu Ramkumarpandian, Sangiliyandi Gurunathan
Angiogenesis, July, 2011
Sardarpasha Sheikpranbabu, Ravinarayanan Haribalaganesh, Elayappan Banumathi, Namagiri Sirishkumar, Kyung-Jin Lee, Sangiliyandi Gurunathan
Life Sciences, September 2011
Kulbhushan Tikoo, Abhijit Babaji Shinde, Chanchal Gupta, Gopabandhu Jena
Cancer Science, October 2011
6) Isolation and Characterization of Goat Retinal Microvascular Endothelial Cells
Ravinarayanan Haribalaganesh, Elayappan Banumathi, Sardarpasha Sheikpranbabu, Venkataraman Deepak, Namagiri Sirishkumar, Sangiliyandi Gurunathan
In Vitro Cellular & Developmental Biology Animal, October 2011
Sardarpasha Sheikpranbabu, Haribalaganesh Ravinarayanan, Banumathi Elayappan, Park Jongsun, Sangiliyandi Gurunathan
Vascular Pharmacology, November 2011
Ravinarayanan Haribalaganesh, Sardarpasha Sheikpranbabu, Elayappan Banumathi, Sangiliyandi Gurunathan
Experimental Eye Research, January 2012
Elayappan Banumathi, Sardarpasha Sheikpranbabu, Ravinarayanan Haribalaganesh, Sangiliyandi Gurunathan
Experimental Eye Research, January 2012
Charitha Gangadharan, Maikho Thoh, Sunil K Manna
Breast Cancer Research and Treatment, March 2013
11) Oleandrin-mediated expression of Fas potentiates apoptosis in tumor cells
Yashin Sreenivasan, Pongali B Raghavendra, Sunil K Manna
Journal of Clinical Immunology, April 2013
Pongali B Raghavendra, Yashin Sreenivasan, Govindarajan T Ramesh, Sunil K Manna
Apoptosis: An International Journal on Programmed Cell Death, May 2013
Priyambada Parhi, Chandana Mohanty, Sanjeeb Kumar Sahoo
Acta Biomaterialia, June 2013
Kanchana Amarnath, Jayanthi Kumar, Tejesh Reddy, Vakka Mahesh, Senniyanallur Rathakrishnan Ayyappan, Jayshree Nellore
Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces, November 2013
15) A PLETHORA-auxin Transcription Module Controls Cell Division Plane Rotation Through MAP65 and CLASP
Pankaj Dhonukshe, Daan A Weits, Alfredo Cruz-Ramirez, Eva E Deinum, Simon H Tindemans, Klementina Kakar, Kalika Prasad, Ari Pekka Mähönen, Chris Ambrose,
Michiko Sasabe, Guy Wachsmann, Marijn Luijten, Tom Bennett, Yasunori Machida,
Renze Heidstra, Geoffrey Wasteneys, Bela M Mulder, Ben Scheres
Cell, November 2013
Abhalaxmi Singh, Fahima Dilnawaz, Sujeet Mewar, Uma Sharma, N R Jagannathan,
Sanjeeb Kumar Sahoo
ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, March 2014
Rishi Kumar Sharma, S C Sharma, P Kumari, Sudish Kumar, Ying T Xing, Uday Prabhakarrao Deshpande, Thoudinja Shripathi, Elisa Zaitovitch
Journal of Applied Physics, June 2014
18) Study of Defect-induced Ferromagnetism in Hydrogenated Anatase TiO2:Co
Rishi Kumar Singhal, Arvind Samariya, Sudhish Kumar, Ying T Xing, D C Jain,
Satya Narayan Dolia, Uday Prabhakarrao Deshpande, Thoudinja Shripathi,
Elisa B Saitovitch
Journal of Applied Physics, July 2014
Arunava Dasgupta, Pratik Datta, Manikuntala Kundu, Joyoti Basu
Microbiology, July 2015
Byoungduck Park, Bokyung Sung, Vivek R Yadav, Madan M Chaturvedi, Bharat B Aggarwal
Biochemical Pharmacology, February 2016
Dibyendu Talukdar, Tulika Talukdar
Plant Science Today, June 2016
Abulaish Ansari, Mohammed Tarique, Renu Tuteja
PLOS ONE, June 2016
Sharad Kumar Dwivedi, Santosh Kumar
Physiology and Molecular Biology of Plants: An International Journal of Functional Plant Biology, July 2016
Subash C Gupta, Simone Reuter, Kanokkarn Phromnoi, Byoungduck Park, Padmanabhan S Hema, Mangalam Nair, Bharat B Aggarwal
The Journal of Biological Chemistry, August 2016
Sahdeo Prasad, Vivek R Yadav, Chitra Sundaram, Simone Reuter, Padmanabhan S Hema, Mangalam S Nair, Madan M Chaturvedi, Bharat B Aggarwal
The Journal of Biological Chemistry, August 2016
Dibyendu Talukdar
The Scientific World Journal, August 2016
Dibyendu Talukdar, Tulika Talukdar
BioMed Research International, September 2016
Dibyendu Talukdar
Environmental and Experimental Biology, September 2016
S Ashokkumar, S Ravi, V Kathiravan, S Velmurugan
Spectrochimica Acta Part A, Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, September 2016
Babar Ali Shah
Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, Parts A/B/C, November 2016
31) Death-Associated Protein Kinase Controls STAT3 Activity in Intestinal Epithelial Cells
Saritha Chakilam, Muktheshwar Gandesiri, Tilman T Rau, Abbas Agaimy, Mahadevan Vijayalakshmi, Jelena Ivanovska, Ralph M Wirtz, Jan Schulze-Luehrmann, Natalya Benderska, Nadine Wittkopf, Ajithavalli Chellappan, Petra Ruemmele, Michael Vieth, Margret Rave-Fränk, Hans Christiansen, Arndt Hartmann,
Clemens Neufert, Raja Atreya, Christoph Becker,Pablo Steinberg, Regine Schneider-Stock
The American Journal of Pathology, December 2016
Jia-Ping Wu, Chin-Chuan Tsai, Yu-Lan Yeh, Yueh-Min Lin, Chien-Chung Lin, Cecelia Hsuan Day, Chia-Yao Shen, V Vijaya Padma, Lung-Fa Pan, Chih-Yang Huang
Protoplasma, January 2017
Dibyendu Talukdar, Tulika Talukdar
Tropical Plant Research, March 2017
Dibyendu Talukdar
ISRN Agronomy, April 2017
Dibyendu Talukdar, Amal K Biswas
Cytologia, May 2017
Shashi Prakash Dwivedi, Satpal Sharma, Raghvendra Kumar Mishra
Procedia Materials Science, March 2018
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Ashutosh Tiwari, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biosensors & Bioelectronics, April 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Ranajit Das, Paramita Karfa, Sunil Kumar, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biosensors & Bioelectronics, April 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Analytica Chimica Acta, April 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Raksha Choudhary, Ashutosh Tiwari, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biosensors & Bioelectronics, April 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Ranajit Das, Paramita Karfa, Sunil Kumar, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biosensors & Bioelectronics, April 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biosensors & Bioelectronics, April 2018
Paramita Karfa, Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Deepak Kumar, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biosensors & Bioelectronics, April 2018
Shadan Ali, Aamir Ahmad, Sanjeev Banerjee, Subhash Padhye, Kristin Dominiak, Jacqueline M Shaffert, Zhiwei Wang, Philip A Philip, Fazlul H Sarkar
Cancer Research, September 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Paramita Karfa, Sunil Kumar, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, October 2018
Saurabh Sharma, Sreejoyee Ghosh, Lalit Kumar Singh, Ashish Sarkar, Rajesh Malhotra, Onkar Prasad Garg, Yogendra Singh, Radhey Shyam Sharma, Darshan Singh Bhakuni, Taposh Kumar Das, Sagarika Biswas
PLOS ONE, October 2018
Paramita Karfa, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Journal of Materials Chemistry A, December 2018
Yogesh Kumar, Isha Kapoor, Kainat Khan, Gatha Thacker, Mohd Parvez Khan
The Journal of Biological Chemistry, January 2019
V Abhilash Kumar, C H Balachiranjeevi, S Bhaskar Naik, R Rambabu, G Rehka, G Harika, S K Hajira, K Pranathi, M Anila, M Kousik, S Vijay Kumar, A Yugander, J Aruna, T Dilip Kumar, K Vijaya Sudhakara Rao, A S Hari Prasad, M S Madhav, G S Laha, S M Balachandran, M S Prasad, B C Viraktamath, V Ravindra Babu, R M Sundaram
Frontiers in Plant Science, January 2019
Menaka Pandey, Partha Sarathi Chowdhury, Achintya Kumar Dutta, Pradeep Kumar, Sourav Pal
RSC Advances, February 2019
Kamini Tripathi, Alok Kumar Singh, Avinash Kumar Sonkar, Anand Prakash, Jagat Kumar Roy, Lallan Mishra
Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical, February 2019
Priyadarshi Roy Chowdhury, Krishna G Bhattacharyya
RSC Advances, February 2019
Shashi Prakash Dwivedi, Satpal Sharma
Metallography, Microstructure, and Analysis, February 2019
Jasmine George, Madhulika Singh, Amit Kumar Srivastava, Kulpreet Bhui, Preeti Roy, Pranav Kumar Chaturvedi, Yogeshwer Shukla
PLOS ONE, April 2019
Shital Magar, Deepika Nayak, Umesh B Mahajan, Kalpesh R Patil, Sachin D Shinde, Sameer N Goyal, Shivang Swaminarayan, Chandragouda R Patil, Shreesh Ojha, Chanakya Nath Kundu
Scientific Reports, June 2019
Naba K Sahoo, Raj B Tokas, Sudhakar Thakur
Applied Surface Science, December 2015
Naba K Sahoo, Sudhakar Thakur, Raj B Tokas, A Biswas, N M Kamble
Applied Surface Science, January 2007
58) Activation of p38MAPK by repetitive low-grade oxidative stress leads to pro-survival effects
Sanghamitra Raha, Prosenjit Sen, Kumar Chakraborty
Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA), December 2007
59) Effect of trimetazidine on renal ischemia/reperfusion injury in rats.
Sanghamitra Raha, Prosenjit Sen, Kumar Chakraborty
Pharmacological Research, December 2007
Julie S Bose, Vijay Gangan, Ravi Prakash, Swatantra Kumar Jain, Sunil K Manna
Journal of Medicinal Chemistry, February 2013
Moutushy Mitra, Ranjita Misra, Anju Harilal, Sanjeeb K Sahoo, Subramanian Krishnakumar
Molecular Vision, June 2013
Soumyadipta Pal
Computational Materials Science, August 2013
P Mohanty, J Das
Plant Growth Regulation, December 2013
64) Isolated eccentric lingual diphtheria: A relevance
Basavaraj P Belaldavar, Nitin R Ankle, Ashwin V Gajendran, Ratkal Kedarnath
Indian Journal of Pathology & Microbiology, March 2014
K Elumalai, S Velmurugan, S Ravi, V Kathiravan, S Ashokkumar
Spectrochimica Acta Part A, Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, February 2015
66) Tunable plasmon resonance of semi-spherical nanoporous gold nanoparticles
Pratap K Sahoo, Dong Wang, Peter Schaaf
Materials Research Express, March 2015
67) Comparison of Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of A356/SiC Metal Matrix Composites Produced by Two Different Melting Routes
Shashi Prakash Dwivedi, Satpal Sharma, Raghvendra Kumar Mishra
International Journal of Manufacturing Engineering, April 2015
Swapnil Moghe, Nitin Saini, Anjali Moghe
National Journal of Maxillofacial Surgery, April 2015
Saptarshi Chatterjee, Keka Sarkar
Biotechnology Letters, April 2015
Mohd Zahid Rizvi, Arun Kumar Kukreja, Narendra Singh Bisht
Physiology and Molecular Biology of Plants: An International Journal of Functional Plant Biology, October 2015
Syed Mohmad Shah, Neha Saini, Syma Ashraf, Manoj Kumar Singh, Rdhey Sham Manik, Suresh Kumar Singla, Prabhat Palta, Manmohan Singh Chauhan
Biochimie, December 2015
Preetha Anand, Bokyung Sung, Ajaikumar B Kunnumakkara, Kallikat N Rajasekharan, Bharat B Aggarwal
Biochemical Pharmacology, February 2016
Prakasam Gopinath, Rajnish Kumar Singh, Mohammad Askandar Iqbal, Ashu Bhan Tiku, Rameshwar N K Bamezai
The Journal of Biological Chemistry, May 2016
Janhvi Mishra Rawat, Balwant Rawat, Susmita Mishra, Aakriti Bhandari, Rajneesh K Agnihotri, Anup Chandra
Physiology and Molecular Biology of Plants: An International Journal of Functional Plant Biology, July 2016
75) Morphological Evolution of Polyaniline and its Interaction with Amphiphiles
Kingshuk Dutta, Patit Paban Kundu
RSC Advances, August 2016
Dibyendu Talukdar, Tulika Talukdar
BioMed Research International, September 2016
77) Acropigmentation of Kitamura with Immigration Delay Disease: A Rare Entity
Sumir Kumar, Bharat Bhushan Mahajan, Nidhi Kamra, Pritish A Bhoyar
Indian Dermatology Online Journal, September 2016
78) Synthesis of silver nanoparticles using A. indicum leaf extract and their antibacterial activity
S Ashokkumar, S Ravi, V Kathiravan, S Velmurugan
Spectrochimica Acta Part A, Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, January 2017
Manasmita Das, Prasanta Dhak, Satyajit Gupta, Debasish Mishra, Tapas K Maiti, Amit Basak, Panchanan Pramanik
Nanotechnology, October 2016
Krishna Dutt Chauhan, R K Soni, Harjeet Singh
International Journal of Plastics Technology, November 2016
S Ashokkumar, S Ravi, S Velmurugan
Spectrochimica Acta Part A, Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, December 2016
82) Influence of Humic Acid on the Stability and Bacterial Toxicity of Zinc Oxide Nanoparticles in Water
K Akhil, Preethy Chandran, S Sudheer Khan
Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology B: Biology, January 2017
83) In vitro clonal propagation of annatto (Bixa oreliana L.)
Marie-Claire D’Souza, Madhuri Sharon
In Vitro Cellular & Developmental Biology – Plant, January 2017
Archana N Rai, Srinath Tamirisa, KV Rao, Vinay Kumar, P Suprasanna
Plant Molecular Biology, January 2017
85) Silymarin Accelerates Liver Regeneration after Partial Hepatectomy
Jia-Ping Wu, Chin-Chuan Tsai, Yu-Lan Yeh, Yueh-Min Lin, Chien-Chung Lin, Cecelia Hsuan Day, Chia-Yao Shen, V Vijaya Padma, Lung-Fa Pan, Chih-Yang Huang
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine (Ecam), January 2017
86) Luminescence enhancement of bluish-green Sr2Al2SiO7:Eu2+ phosphor by dysprosium co-doping
Ishwar Prasad Sahu, D P Bisen, Nameeta Brahme, Raunak Kumar Tamrakar
Journal of Luminescence, March 2017
Naba K Sahoo, Sudhakar Thakur, Raj B Tokas, N M Kamble
Applied Surface Science, July 2017
K Elumalai, S Velmurugan, S Ravi, V Kathiravan, S Ashokkumar
Spectrochimica Acta Part A, Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, August 2017
Prabuddha Dey, Monami Chakraborty, Maulik R Kamdar, Mrinal K Maiti
PLOS ONE, October 2017
Prabuddha Dey, Nikunj Mall, Atrayee Chattopadhyay, Monami Chakraborty, Mrinal K Maiti
PLOS ONE, October 2017
Giridhara R Jayandharan, George Aslanidi, Stephen C Jahn, George Q Perrin, Roland W Herzog, Arun Srivastava
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, December 2017
Anshul Watts, Sunil K Singh, Jyoti Bhadouria, Vasupalli Naresh, Ashok K Bishoy, K A Geetha, Rohit Chamola, Debasis Pattanayak, Shripad R Bhat,
Frontiers in Plant Science, January 2018
Mehulkumar L Savaliya, Bharatkumar Z Dholakiya
Applied Catalysis A: General, April 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Retwik Parui, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biosensors & Bioelectronics, April 2018
Sapan Kumar Sharma, Nandini Gautam, Narender Singh Atri
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine (Ecam), May 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, May 2018
Raksha Choudhary, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, May 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, May 2018
Shashi Prakash Dwivedi, Satpal Sharma, Raghvendra Kumar Mishra
Advances in Manufacturing, July 2018
Ajaikumar B Kunnumakkara, Haruyo Ichikawa, Preetha Anand, Chiramel J Mohankumar, Padmanabhan S Hema, Mangalam S Nair, Bharat B Aggarwal
Molecular Cancer Therapeutics, September 2018
Bin Bao, Shadan Ali, Dejuan Kong, Sanila H Sarkar, Zhiwei Wang, Sanjeev Banerjee, Amro Aboukameel, Subhash Padhye, Philip A Philip, Fazlul H Sarkar
PLOS ONE, October 2018
Ekat Roy, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Chemical Engineering Journal, October 2018
Sapan Kumar Sharma, Nandini Gautam, Narender Singh Atri
BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine, October 2018
Dharman Govindaraj, Mariappan Rajan, Murugan A Munusamy, Abdullah A Alarfaj, Akon Higuchi, S Suresh Kumar
Materials Chemistry and Physics, October 2018
Santanu Patra, Raksha Choudhary, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biosensors & Bioelectronics, November 2018
Santanu Patra, Raksha Choudhary, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Journal of Materials Chemistry C, December 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Biomaterials Science, December 2018
108) Doping, strain, defects and magneto-optical properties of Zn1-xMnxO nanocrystals
Prashant K Sharma, Ranu K Dutta, R J Choudhary, Avinash C Pandey
CrystEngComm, December 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
RSC Advances, December 2018
Paramita Karfa, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K Sharma
Journal of Materials Chemistry B, December 2018
Srabasti Sengupta, Saba Naz, Ishani Das, Abdul Ahad, Avinash Padhi, Sumanta Kumar Naik, Geetanjali Ganguli, Kali Prasad Pattanaik, Sunil Kumar Raghav, Vinay Kumar Nandicoori, Avinash Sonawane
The Journal of Biological Chemistry, January 2019
Dinesh Kumar Parandhaman, Luke Elizabeth Hanna, Sujatha Narayanan
PLOS ONE, January 2019
Somasundaram Kaviya, Jayadevan Santhanalakshmi, Balasubramanian Viswanathan
Journal of Nanotechnology, March 2019
114) Inhibition Effect of Substituted Thiadiazoles on Corrosion Activity of N80 Steel in HCl Solution
Mahendra Yadav, Sumit Kumar, Debasis Behera
Journal of Metallurgy, March 2019
115) Corrosion Inhibition of Tubing Steel during Acidization of Oil and Gas Wells
Mahendra Yadav, Simt Kumar, Premanand N Yadav
Journal of Petroleum Engineering, March 2019
116) Polyethylenimine nanoparticles as efficient transfecting agents for mammalian cells
Surendra Nimesh, Anita Goyal, Vikas Pawar, Sujatha Jayaraman, Pradeep Kumar, Ramesh Chandra, Yogendra Singh, Kailash C Gupta
Journal of Controlled Release, March 2019
Vinay K Tripathi, Vivek Kumar, Abhishek K Singh, Mahendra P Kashyap, Sadaf Jahan, Ankita Pandey, Sarfaraz Alam, Feroz Khan, Vinay K Khanna, Sanjay Yadav, Mohtshim Lohani, Aditya B Pant
PLOS ONE, March 2019
118) Imidazolyl-PEI modified nanoparticles for enhanced gene delivery
Archana Swami, Anita Aggarwal, Atul Pathak, Soma Patnaik, Pradeep Kumar, Yogendra Singh, Kailash C Gupta
International Journal of Pharmaceutics, March 2019
Narayanaswamy Sharadamma, Yadumurthy Harshavardhana, Apoorva Ravishankar, Praveen Anand, Nagasuma Chandra, K. Muniyappa
Journal of Biological Chemistry, 2015
Ankana Tiwari, Swamy Shivananda, Kodaganur S. Gopinath, Arun Kumar
The Journal of Biological Chemistry, April 2019
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
RSC Advances, December 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
RSC Advances, December 2018
123) Doping, strain, defects and magneto-optical properties of monodispersed Zn1-xMnxO nanocrystals
Raksha Choudhary, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Crystal Engineering Communication, December 2018
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
ACS Biomaterials Science & Engineering, February 2018
Raksha Choudhary, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
ACS Biomaterials Science & Engineering, May 2018
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Ranajit Das, Paramita Karfa, Sunil Kumar, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Biosensors and Bioelectronics, December 2018
Raksha Choudhary, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Biosensors and Bioelectronics, February 2019
Further, database shows only 24 retracted from India due to Concerns/Issues About Image.
The search criteria used were:
Reason(s) for Retraction: +Concerns/Issues About Image
Affiliation: India
Just use image duplication or something like that. I don’t recall what I used, but I did get 118 papers when I used terms such as image manipulation and image duplication. These terms were not together.
Dear Mr Prasad
The article is misleading. The fact is that retraction of article is much higher in number in other countries than India. Readers, please have a look to following data
Number of retractions country-wise:
CHINA 9186
USA 2092
INDIA 969
Number of retractions city-wise:
CALIFORNIA 386
NEW YORK 348
LONDON 229
DELHI 105
The article clearly states: “Compared with the U.S and China, there are relatively fewer papers from India that gets published. But Bik’s study found India had 1.93 higher-than-predicted ratio of papers containing image duplication.”
Mere retraction of the research papers should not suffice. These so called great scientists should be debarred from their high positions which they gained out of this shamil act. Such activities tarnish the image of not only individual scientist but the image of the country as well. The Modi Govt is taking very strict actions against corrupt civil officials, even they are asked to take the voluntary retirement, these so called great scientists should also be punished that way only , as it also falls in the corruption category.