The Department of Applied Chemistry at IIT Dhanbad has 45 papers listed on Pubpeer for image duplication and/or manipulation. Of the 45, 19 papers are of Dr. Rashmi Madhuri’s. The 19 papers of Dr. Madhuri are in addition to the 25 papers that have already been retracted. Dr. Madhuri is already under investigation by the institute.
The Department of Applied Chemistry at the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Dhanbad first became infamous when 25 papers of Dr. Rashmi Madhuri (coauthered with Dr. Prashant Sharma of the Department of Applied Physics at the same institute) were retracted and another 19 papers were still listed on Pubpeer website for problematic images. On closer scrutiny, another 25 papers by other faculty members from the same department were found to be listed on the website.
In addition to the 25 papers, there are about 10 papers that have already been retracted or corrected for image duplication between papers. Of the 25 papers listed on Pubpeer, Prof. Sagar Pal and Prof. Mahendra Yadav have the most — nine and 10, respectively. They are not co-authors in any of the 25 papers.
Except for a couple of papers, almost all the papers have problems with image reuse in more than one paper. There are instances where the same image has been reused in three more papers, though the experiment or the material being studied is different in each case.
Retraction for reusing images
A 2013 paper in the Journal of Metallurgy by Prof. Yadav was retracted along with three other papers (here, here and here) by him. The retraction notice published by the Journal of Metallurgy for the 2013 paper reads: “The article was found to contain images reused in several other articles published by Mahendra Yadav and colleagues. The details of the reuse of images [within the same paper] are as follows: Figure 9(b) is similar to Figure 11b, Figure 17b, Figure 14b, and Figure 5b. Figure 9(c) is similar to Figure 11c, Figure 17c, and Figure 14c. In particular, Figure 9 shares the same image of a sample in HCl as Figure 11 and the same image in the presence of an inhibitor, but these represent different inhibitors in each article, AMPT, and BAL, respectively.
“We asked the authors to provide the underlying uncropped and unadjusted scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images, the raw data, and details of how the experiments were conducted.
“The corresponding author, Dr. Yadav, said the SEM work was outsourced but did not give details on where, when, or by whom this work was performed. The equipment is described as a “JEOL JSM-6380 LA analytical scanning electron microscope” in this article. However, there is no description of the scanning electron microscope in this paper and in this paper it is described as a “Scanning Electron Microscope model SEM Jeol JSM-5800.” These are not the same model of microscope, despite these articles sharing some of the same SEM images.
“Dr. Yadav provided us with replacement figures. However, they were identical for two of the articles, despite representing experiments with the inhibitors AMPT and ODAEODI, respectively. We were not told how these images were generated, the images were of low resolution, and the text in the images was illegible.”
Similarly, a retraction note published for a 2014 paper by Prof. Yadav in the journal Acta Metallurgica Sinica (English Letter) reads: “The editor has retracted this article because Figure 7a-7d, as well as parts of the text were duplicated from the following article. There is also substantial overlap with article that has been retracted due to duplicate publication. The data reported in this article are therefore unreliable.”
Dr. Madhuri’s saga
A fact-finding committee comprising four members began investigating in March last year when more than two dozen papers of Dr. Madhuri and Dr. Sharma were retracted. In August 2018, Prof. Rajiv Shekhar, Director of IIT Dhanbad told me that the investigation has been completed. He said scientific misconduct appeared serious and may attract major penalty.
The researchers would be given a chance to contest the findings, he had said. When last contacted about two weeks ago, Prof. Shekhar said the investigation is yet to be completed. He refused to say when it might be completed.
Training students in the fine art of image manipulation
Like how Dr. Madhuri was a co-author of 16 of 51 papers published by her PhD supervisor Prof. Bhim Bali Prasad from the Department of Chemistry at Banaras Hindu University (BHU), Varanasi, her students — Santanu Patra and Ekta Roy — too are co-authors in many of Dr. Madhuri’s papers still listed on Pubpeer. Santanu Patra and Ekta Roy are co-authors in 15 and 11 papers, respectively.
Problematic papers listed on Pubpeer website
Goutam Hatui, Ganesh Chandra Nayak, G. Udayabhanu, Yogendra Kumar Mishra, Devendra Deo Pathak
New Journal of Chemistry (2017)
Mahendra Yadav, Laldeep Gope, Nilam Kumari, Premanand Yadav
Journal of Molecular Liquids (2016)
Mahendra Yadav, Laldeep Gope, Tarun Kanti Sarkar
Research on Chemical Intermediates (2016)
Mahendra Yadav, Tarun Kanti Sarkar, Taniya Purkait
Journal of Molecular Liquids (2015)
5) Corrosion inhibitive properties of some new isatin derivatives on corrosion of N80 steel in 15% HCl
Mahendra Yadav, Usha Sharma, Premanand Yadav
International Journal of Industrial Chemistry (2013)
M. Yadav, R. R. Sinha, Sumit Kumar, T. K. Sarkar
RSC Advances (2015)
Dharmendra Kumar Singh, Eno E. Ebenso, Mantu Kumar Singh, Debasis Behera, G. Udayabhanu, Rohith P. John
Journal of Molecular Liquids (2018)
8) Nontoxic corrosion inhibitors for N80 steel in hydrochloric acid
M. Yadav, Debasis Behera, Usha Sharma
Arabian Journal of Chemistry (2016)
Dharmendra Kumar Singh, Santosh Kumar, G. Udayabhanu, Rohith P. John
Journal of Molecular Liquids (2016)
Sagar Pal, M.K. Gorain, A. Giri, A. Bandyopadhyay, A.B. Panda
International Journal of Biological Macromolecules (2011)
Sagar Pal, Gautam Sen, Sandipta Ghosh, R.P. Singh
Carbohydrate Polymers (2018)
12) A novel polymeric flocculant based on polyacrylamide grafted carboxymethylstarch
Gautam Sen, Ranvijay Kumar, S. Ghosh, Sagar Pal
Carbohydrate Polymers (2009)
Gautam Sen, Sandipta Ghosh, Usha Jha, Sagar Pal
Chemical Engineering Journal (2011)
Amrita Biswas, Punita Mourya, Dipanjan Mondal, Sagar Pal, G. Udayabhanu
Journal of Molecular Liquids (2018)
Amrita Biswas, Sagar Pal, G. Udayabhanu
Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology (2017)
Sagar Pal, S. Ghorai, M.K. Dash, S. Ghosh, G. Udayabhanu
Journal of Hazardous Materials (2011)
Raghunath Das, Soumitra Ghorai, Sagar Pal
Chemical Engineering Journal (2013)
18) Acrylic acid grafted guargum–nanosilica membranes for transdermal diclofenac delivery
Arindam Giri, Tridib Bhunia, Samir Ranjan Mishra, Luna Goswami, Asit Baran Panda, Sagar Pal, Abhijit Bandyopadhyay
Carbohydrate Polymers (2013)
Soumen Chandra, Angshuman Ray Chowdhuri, Triveni Kumar Mahto, Arpita Samui, Sumanta Kumar Sahu
RSC Advances (2016)
Angshuman Ray Chowdhuri, Satyajit Tripathy, Soumen Chandra, Somenath Roy, Sumanta Kumar Sahu
RSC Advances (2015)
Goutam Hatui, Ganesh Chandra Nayak, G. Udayabhanu, Yogendra Kumar Mishra, Devendra Deo Pathak
New Journal of Chemistry (2017)
22) Targeted synthesis of cadmium(ii) Schiff base complexes towards corrosion inhibition on mild steel
Mriganka Das, Amrita Biswas, Bidyut Kumar Kundu, Shaikh M. Mobin, G. Udayabhanu, Suman Mukhopadhyay
RSC Advances (2017)
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Ashutosh Tiwari, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Biosensors and Bioelectronics (2017)
Shrabani Mondal, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Journal of Alloys and Compounds (2015)
Shrabani Mondal, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Advanced Materials Letters (2017)
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Environmental Science & Technology (2015)
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
RSC Advances (2014)
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Chemical Engineering Journal (2016)
Sunil Kumar, Paramita Karfa, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
RSC Advances (2016)
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Analytica Chimica Acta (2016)
Shrabani Mondal, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Journal of Materials Chemistry C (2017)
Santanu Patra, Raksha Choudhary, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Nano Energy (2016)
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Chemical Engineering Journal (2016)
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Colloids and Surfaces B Biointerfaces (2016)
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Shubham Saha, Deepak Kumar, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Chemical Engineering Journal (2017)
Ekta Roy, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Talanta (2014)
Santanu Patra, Ekta Roy, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry (2016)
Suryakanti Debata, Santanu Patra, Sanchari Banerjee, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Applied Surface Science (2018)
Trupti R. Das, Santanu Patra, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Journal of Colloid and Interface Science (2018)
Santanu Patra, Raksha Choudhary, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Graphene Bioelectronics (2018)
41) Polymeric iron oxide-graphene nanocomposite as a trace level sensor of vitamin C
Trupti R. Das, Suchit Kumar Jena, Rashmi Madhuri, Prashant K. Sharma
Applied Surface Science (2018)
M. Yadav, R.R. Sinha, S. Kumar, I. Bahadur, E.E. Ebenso
M. Yadav, T. K. Sarkar, I. B. Obot
RSC Advances (2016)
M. Yadav, Dipti Sharma, T.K. Sarkar
Journal of Molecular Liquids (2015)
45) Isatin compounds as corrosion inhibitors for N80 steel in 15% HCl
M. Yadav, Usha Sharma, P.N. Yadav
I heard they are married to each other. I am surprised none of the articles mentioned this.
This a qualification for coming to position in India, more retraction more and more higher position. In BARC a person with maximum retraction got DS with director post. Pl. Check retraction from BARC in Google, you will see many papers with retraction and all are either OS OR DS either director or HOD post. No action against them but promoted to next higher grades
Papers listed in pubpeer does not necessarily mean that all of those are problematic.
Please choose the papers which have problems and mention the number. Otherwise, it is just a article here, reporting a “large number of papers in pubpeer” to attract the readers to this post. Please do not try to damage of the institutes unnecessarily. Above all, honesty in research completely depends on the person who conducts the research. The institutes do not have role or support for doing misconduct. Please report research misconducts directly mentioning the name of the fraudsters in the title of your articles instead of naming the institutes in your post. It’s not easy to regain the reputation once it lost for the institutes. It’s hard earned.
I don’t mention papers just because they are posted on PubPeer. These have been cross-checked. And any justification for the retracted papers, too? Much as I mention the institute’s name when I write about good work done by its researchers, I do mention the institute’s name when the news is not to your liking. The institute stands to gain or lose depending on how its faculty/students perform.
When the article is about more than one person, do you really expect me to mention the names of 5-10 people in the heading/title?
And about regaining reputation, please do tell me why the investigation into Dr. Rashmi Madhuri and Dr. Prashant Sharma, who have 25 papers retracted, which was started in March last year has still not reached its logical end? Why is there a delay despite the fact-finding committee finding serious misconduct, as the director himself told me? The more the institute delays, the more muck will be thrown.
I don’t mention papers just because they are posted on PubPeer.
This is an important point. Thank you for checking the entries. Papers can be posted on PubPeer to point out an interesting corollary, or to correct what are obviously unintended mistakes. Or a critic can be completely wrong (or malicious).
SEE THE PETITION ON DHANBAD INVESTIGATION HERE.
https://www.change.org/p/malpractice-and-research-fraud-at-ism-iit-dhanbad